• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Wrecked CJ-8 Insurance questions

The adjuster that came out was very nice and felt pretty strongly that it wouldnt be totaled. He was just contracted by my insurance company to come oit and look at it. We'll have to wait and see how the American Collectors Insurance handles it from here. I'll post as it progresses.
 
No questions asked. They estimate the damage at $4,500. Now I just need to find a shop that will fix it right. Thinking of hitting up a couple of hot rod shops in town that do good metal work, unless there are any other recommendations.
 
Right on! Good to hear.

Make sure when you get estimates of repair that all repairs are explained in detail. This is so you know it's being done right. (Minimal filler, metal replacement, butt welding and smoothing instead of lap welded repairs, ect. If I was doing that repair, I'd separate the upper cowl at the seam and replace it complete. Same with the side- split at the floor seam and butt weld in a patch panel. Once the welds are dressed inner and outer, you'll never know it happened.
 
Great point, thank you Randy. To that end the insurance company asked that whoever I go with to make sure before they begin any work that they take everything apart and list out anything else that needed to be replaced. They knew that the adjuster wouldn't likely be able to see all damage i.e. behind the dash, so I can submit any additional damage as supplemental cost to the insurance company for approval before thet start working on it.
 
This is great to hear as I recently set up my insurance for the Scrambler... did mine with State Farm though.

Makes me want to go back and re-read all the fine print...
 
Just wondering how this turned out, I've been thinking about switching insurance and wondering if you've gotten this resolved yet.
 
Still in the works...but getting close. I realized after getting my check and estimate in the mail from the insurance company that they only allocated for $42 dollars an hour for the body shop work. That is pretty typical and reasonable at most body shops for most jobs where they are just slapping on new body parts. However, the damage to my jeep wasn't a regular body shop fix being that all the majority of the damage was to the tub and cowl. Knowing that I wanted someone that had good metal working skills I figured I would take it to a hot rod shop and both places I took the pictures to said they could definitely fix it without a problem (of course they have only seen pictures). Both hot rod shops quoted $65 an hour and when I told that to the insurance company they said that hourly rate was really high and that I needed to try and find a Jeep specific place that could fix my Jeep and hopefully get the hourly rate down. So, I did the leg work and called a well known outfit for Jeep Restoration whose initials might be CB that is about an hour and half drive from me and left them messages on three occasions without ever getting a phone call back. I assume that since the CB website states that they start restorations at $15k that they probably didn't want to mess with me. After that fail I went out to a local off road shop that does body work. I showed them the pictures of the damage, they made a grimace and then proceeded to tell me in a very non-confident tone that they could probably fix it and get it about 95% there but would not be able to guarantee the work but their hourly rate was the $42 an hour. Well that didn't make me feel good about leaving it there with them and my thought was that they are used to getting these built up rigs in there that have been rolled or torn up while rock crawling and they are used to just banging out the dents putting a fresh coat of paint on and sending them back out to the trails and that unfortunately is not what I am looking for. So, I called the insurance company back and explained to them what I have just written and they said to go ahead and take it to the hot rod shop but he needed them to look over the Jeep figure out everything that they need to fix put a price on it and then submit back to them for approval before working on it. The insurance company just wants a set budget so they are not getting taken advantage of which seems fair to me. That being said I am dropping off my Jeep Monday morning at the hot rod shop for them to see the Jeep in person. Once they see it they will put together the estimate of what they feel it will take to get the job done which will be sent to the insurance company for approval. Fingers crossed that they approve it because I truly believe that this will be a better outcome for the repair of my jeep than taking it to a regular body shop. I'll keep the forum posted on how the next chapter plays out.
 
Hey thanks for the quick update, it seems you've made the right choice on getting your 8 repaired, lets hope the insurance co. agrees also. I went to the American Collectors website and they seem to be reasonable in both price and driving requirements. One thing I didn't see was any reference to off roading the insured vehicle, but for me that doesn't much matter as any damage off road would be my responsibility(unless somebody hit me while off road, so maybe it does matter!) Haven't decided yet. I hope you get your situation resolved to your satisfaction and appreciate keeping us posted on the outcome.
 
From what I can see I would not replace metal in the rocker. It looks like it could be pulled back into position and strightened. For $4500 I would expect it to be fixed perfectly and either the paint blended to perfection or a complete repaint. Any shop you have it done at should gaurentte their work. They should have a down draft booth and be very fimilar with classic vehicles. Although I am not a huge fan of CB they should be able to do this work for $4500.
 
Finally have an update, I posted this same thing in another thread but incase someone was searching for insurance in the future, I figured I would close the loop here.

After several weeks and 4 body shops later, I landed at Collins Brothers. They were super helpful and assured me that once they started digging into it that you/I would never be able to tell that there was ever any damage done. In the first meeting he said that the repairs were going to start at $10k minimum and likely be closer to $15k. Well, that worried me because the jeep was going to be totaled at $12,800, 80% of the stated value with insurance, and that's not what I wanted, but knew I was out of options getting anyone to work on it. Fortunately the estimate from collins brothers came back at $8,100 after they did a thorough inspection and and put the pricing on paper. The next hurdle was getting insurance to pay nearly double the amount of what they initially valued the repair cost at, which was $4,500. Kevin from Collins Brothers handled all of the communication with my insurance company and 5 days later, insurance approved all the additional cost. Yay! Finally getting somewhere after nearly three months of dealing with incompetent body shops. Collins Brothers has already started work and expects to be finished within 3- 4 weeks. I now wish I had put a little more effort of getting in touch with collins brothers from the beginning and I probably would have had my jeep back months ago.

At the end of the day, I am super happy with the way Americans Collectors Insurance handled the claim. They never gave me any grief, they were very helpful in answering questions over the phone and ultimately paid nearly double what they originally estimated without any fuss. From my experience they are very reasonable people and offer insurance at an affordable cost while providing great customer service. I highly recommend them.

Thank you again to everyone for all of the great advice. I'll post pictures once all the work is done and the jeep is back home.

You can see my explanation for the gate malfunction here... https://www.cj-8.com/forum/showthread.php?37037-Cowl-and-WIndshield-Base-Need-Help-Sourcing/page2
 
Glad to hear you'll get the Jeep fixed but :eek: on the price they're coming down to. Just wow. Guess all that matters is that they convinced the insurance company.
 
Glad to hear you'll get the Jeep fixed but :eek: on the price they're coming down to. Just wow. Guess all that matters is that they convinced the insurance company.

I know. I'm okay with it though because I have a lot confidence that it will be done right and it won't keep me up at night constantly worrying that it's going to be screwed up even worse. After 3 months with the other body shops, I finally feel at ease with the whole situation. Collins Brothers was pretty close on the pricing of all the parts. The biggest difference came down to the hourly rate. Insurance had initially estimated $42 per hour of labor and Collins Brothers on paper charges $75 an hour for body work labor. But, like I said, I have no doubt it will done correctly and my jeep will probably even come back to me in better shape than it was before the gate fiasco.

Thank you again Eric for your guidance and advice.
 
Is CB close to you? If I were you, I'd be in there checking on things throughout the process just to be sure things are done to your satisfaction and to see how they are getting this done.

Are they repainting the entire Jeep and what did they say on the source for the cowl/sheet metal? Good used from their inventory? Doing the mental math in my head, I'm assuming they'll use part of a tub sitting in their yard and at $75/hr...

But again, you'll have it back right and insurance is paying, that's what matters.
 
Yup, I am actually headed out there this morning. It's about a 1 hour 15 minute drive for me. I made it clear that I want oem, nos or when not available the cleanest straigtest used parts they could find.
 
Yup, I am actually headed out there this morning. It's about a 1 hour 15 minute drive for me. I made it clear that I want oem, nos or when not available the cleanest straigtest used parts they could find.

I just stumbled upon this now! What a sad story but I'm glad it all got worked out, I may have to make the switch over to American classics. Do you have any pictures of the repairs? This has always been my worst nightmare so I'm wanting to know if there really is a way to restore it back to perfection.
 
I actually don't have any pics readily available and I am in Wyoming currently and wont be back with my Jeep until the 20th. The only picture I can share with you right now is one that CB took while they were working on it and posted it on their facebook page. I'll take and upload some more when I am back home.
 

Attachments

  • ImageUploadedByTapatalk1373228329.125556.jpg
    ImageUploadedByTapatalk1373228329.125556.jpg
    24.8 KB · Views: 113
  • ImageUploadedByTapatalk1373228345.988746.jpg
    ImageUploadedByTapatalk1373228345.988746.jpg
    71.7 KB · Views: 114
Long overdue and closing the loop here. Attaching the before pictures again and then the after pictures. It actually turned out better than it was before. American Collectors Insurance made it super simple and were easy to work with and kudos to Collins Bros. for the nice work on my Scrambler and working with the insurance company on my behalf.

Before pictures...

ImageUploadedByTapatalk1379015368.365837.jpg
ImageUploadedByTapatalk1379015380.011453.jpg
ImageUploadedByTapatalk1379015392.866434.jpg
ImageUploadedByTapatalk1379015430.020059.jpg
 
Back
Top