Here are some pictures of my red '83 that I rebuilt. It has the RE 4.5" lift, PLUS a 1" body lift.
35x12.50x15 on factory 15x8 wheels.
And how it sits currently, with 33x12.50x15 on factory15x8 wheels.
A few notes/opinions/personal observations:
1) I am running factory wide track axles
2) 35's will fit, but the springs do settle
3) 35's hit the back of the rear wheel wells when it flexes off road
4) If you keep it on the street/light wheeling, 35's will fit
5) If you take it off road like I do (Pritchett Canyon, for example) 33's are a much better choice, or start cutting sheet metal
And some newer pictures, after the springs have settled after 10,000 miles of driving in one year:
I drive/use this Scrambler a pretty good bit. It sees mud, rocks, sand, daily driving, and cross country trips. For me, the 33's work/fit better, but that is my opinion.