• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Oversteering woes

If the frame shop did a real inspection they should have provided a list of measurements they took at various points on the frame (to determine if the rails are straight, parallel/perpendicular, and have correct spread/separation. I'd be curious to know what the exact numbers are.

It's the shackle that's a little twisted
 
I've been watching this thread but haven't contributed anything yet. I do have a couple of questions, and please excuse me if they have been asked/answered before. I figure after all the new parts with a still persistent issue, let's get another shot at the symptoms.

1. You mention "Way too sensitive, unsafe at over 40MPH." By sensitive do you mean that any small movement of the steering wheel seems to cause a change in direction? Or do you mean that there is too much power assist- meaning that you have no road feel, no pressure against your movements?

2.Is there any excess play in the steering system, now that there are all those new parts? Both with the Jeep running and not running, even a slight movement of the steering wheel should show movement at the tires. Or is there a loose feeling at the wheel, like you can turn between 11:00 and 1:00 without anything moving in the front end?

3.When you dry turn the wheels, (Turn stop to stop without moving forward or backwards), does the front axle appear to be stationary right to left in relation to the frame? Or does the axle shift a bit side to side as you turn?

4.If you center the steering wheel and then bounce the front end up and down, does the steering wheel move left to right corresponding to the jouncing? (Make sure you leave the column unlocked for this. )

5.While driving, do you feel like you're always correcting to make the Jeep go straight? Like you're steering on the top of a ball and there's no real center?

6. A frame shop hopefully did a thorough job. Did you get copies of your thrust angle? Camber and Caster? Toe? Can you post these measurements?

7. Have you tried driving with the track bar disconnected and safely secured out of the way? These things never came with a track bar, it sounds like someone has been battling this issue for awhile. If you have tried this, did it make a difference?

8.Have you checked the centering pins on all 4 springs? Basically, is the axle shifting within the u-bolts? There would be rust powder where movement occurs, usually.

9. Do you have a rear locker? If you do, are your roads rutted/uneven? Does road surface make the issue worse?

10. Does acceleration/deceleration seem to make the problem worse or make it pull left/right?

11. Have you tried a different set of tires? Or at least rotated the tires to see if the symptoms changed?

Please let us know, and if you are unsure of what I'm asking for please ask for clarification . Hoping this can get resolved- hate to see someone spent all that cash with no satisfaction.
 
I've been watching this thread but haven't contributed anything yet. I do have a couple of questions, and please excuse me if they have been asked/answered before. I figure after all the new parts with a still persistent issue, let's get another shot at the symptoms.

1. You mention "Way too sensitive, unsafe at over 40MPH." By sensitive do you mean that any small movement of the steering wheel seems to cause a change in direction? Or do you mean that there is too much power assist- meaning that you have no road feel, no pressure against your movements? I think both

2.Is there any excess play in the steering system, now that there are all those new parts? Both with the Jeep running and not running, even a slight movement of the steering wheel should show movement at the tires. Or is there a loose feeling at the wheel, like you can turn between 11:00 and 1:00 without anything moving in the front end? At first I thought yes, but I have confirmed there is none

3.When you dry turn the wheels, (Turn stop to stop without moving forward or backwards), does the front axle appear to be stationary right to left in relation to the frame? Or does the axle shift a bit side to side as you turn? Axle doesn't move

4.If you center the steering wheel and then bounce the front end up and down, does the steering wheel move left to right corresponding to the jouncing? (Make sure you leave the column unlocked for this. ) when I had the trac bar on it wouldn't, but since I removed the trac bar the front suspension "rolls" more along with the road or movements

5.While driving, do you feel like you're always correcting to make the Jeep go straight? Like you're steering on the top of a ball and there's no real center? Yes, very much so

6. A frame shop hopefully did a thorough job. Did you get copies of your thrust angle? Camber and Caster? Toe? Can you post these measurements?i did not get thrust or camber which I was told should be 0. But caster was +6, toe-in is 3/32nds

7. Have you tried driving with the track bar disconnected and safely secured out of the way? These things never came with a track bar, it sounds like someone has been battling this issue for awhile. If you have tried this, did it make a difference? The track bar is now removed, it definitely isn't as stiff now, but still unsatisfactory

8.Have you checked the centering pins on all 4 springs? Basically, is the axle shifting within the u-bolts? There would be rust powder where movement occurs, usually. Have not checked the rear pins, but front pins have now been changed as of last week. Replaced when new u-bolts when on

9. Do you have a rear locker? If you do, are your roads rutted/uneven? Does road surface make the issue worse? No rear locker

10. Does acceleration/deceleration seem to make the problem worse or make it pull left/right? Yes, I do feel when I decelerate it comes off line

11. Have you tried a different set of tires? Or at least rotated the tires to see if the symptoms changed? I have not tried different tires, but I have had them rotated and re-balanced

Please let us know, and if you are unsure of what I'm asking for please ask for clarification . Hoping this can get resolved- hate to see someone spent all that cash with no satisfaction.

All great questions, thanks Randyzzz
 
It's the shackle that's a little twisted

That's a pretty HD looking shackle to have been bent, but if they are damaged I would replace for sure. Can't get smooth suspension travel when the shackle is trying to swing to the side...
 
1) Did you ever fix the slack in the steering column?

2) You said "deceleration aggravates the situation". Have you checked the rear axle u-bolts and center pins?

3) What type of PS lines do you have, o-ring style or metal flare? The earlier steering boxes are not variable assist, so they give high assist even at high speeds. BUT, if everything else is correct, this won't make the vehicle feel "loose" on the highway. I prefer the variable assist feel, but the earlier style boxes work fine IF everything else is correct.

4) Are the front wheel bearings adjusted correctly? Are the rear axle wheel bearings installed correctly?

5) Does your '82 have narrow track or wide track axles? The narrow track axles do tend to "fight the center hump in asphalt roads" more then the wide track axles. BUT, they still won't make the Jeep dangerous to drive. The road feel is different, I prefer wide track axles. BUT, you should be able to get a safe ride with narrow track axles.

6) Are you 100% sure you don't have a rear locking differential, or even a Trac-Lock LSD without the additive?


Hard to diagnose problems over the internet, i hope you can find a local guru to help you :thumbsup:
 
1) Did you ever fix the slack in the steering column?

This right here. I have not read where the column was replaced or disassembled to correct the only solid problem that's been successfully diagnosed: the tilt steering shaft joint.

Hopefully I just missed it :shrug:
 
What wheel offset/backspacing are you running? This can dramatically change the steering response if you have changed it much from stock. I drove a CJ8 with 33" tires and new steering gear a few weeks ago. It looked like the wheels had much less backspacing than stock. The on center steering response was very vague, but just off center was very quick and hard to manage. The steering was also more sensitive to the slope and inputs from the road. My stock CJ8 steers much much better. From my research, stock 8" wheels had -12mm offset and 4" backspacing.
 
What wheel offset/backspacing are you running? This can dramatically change the steering response if you have changed it much from stock. I drove a CJ8 with 33" tires and new steering gear a few weeks ago. It looked like the wheels had much less backspacing than stock. The on center steering response was very vague, but just off center was very quick and hard to manage. The steering was also more sensitive to the slope and inputs from the road. My stock CJ8 steers much much better. From my research, stock 8" wheels had -12mm offset and 4" backspacing.

Stock CJ rims
 
This right here. I have not read where the column was replaced or disassembled to correct the only solid problem that's been successfully diagnosed: the tilt steering shaft joint.

Hopefully I just missed it :shrug:

What I thought was play in the column in fact was not. If you turn the steering wheel at all, the steering shaft coincides. It's is clear and precise all the way down to the input shaft of the gear box.

Sorry if I did not make this clear.
 
how is your return to zero?
When I finally installed my shims my return to zero got better and the highway speed handling greatly, greatly improved.
I had the exact same problem. FYI--the alignment shops told me it was within spec but I'm a big fan of just throwing money at a problem so I put them in just to see what would happen. I put in 6 degree as well but remember reading that you could go more if needed.
You have a great looking Scrambler, good luck.
 
Thanks for taking the time to answer my questions. I was hoping for a big "Ah Ha" moment form at least one of your answers, but other than confirming your symptoms, there's not alot. Deceleration pull can indicate a thrust angle that is off, which can be caused by a sheared centering pin. Have you measured distance right and left, center of front hub to center of rear hub? Most alignment shops ignore anything but front end adjustments on Jeeps.

Thrust angle:
align_thrustgif-1.jpg


Normally the "steering on a ball" symptom indicates caster wrong (yours looks good), or looseness in the steering intermediate shaft (yours checks OK).

Excessive power assist can aggravate issues, saginaw pumps can be shimmed for less assist but you'll have to find someone who knows his stuff to do that...

Measure rollout on your tires. Chalk the sidewall of each tire, and make a corresponding mark on the ground. Roll Jeep forward one revolution until the chalk on the sidewall is facing down again. Mark the ground. Measure distance between chalk marks on ground. repeat for each tire. All measurements should be almost the same.

I was thinking you had a locker in the rear and were driving on uneven roads. I've pulled lockers out of Jeeps that the sales department couldn't sell because of pulling left then right on test drives. We have very uneven road surfaces here- weather extremes and studded tires make grooves in the pavement- if your track width is off, driving is a chore, but with a locker it's almost unsafe at times.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for taking the time to answer my questions. I was hoping for a big "Ah Ha" moment form at least one of your answers, but other than confirming your symptoms, there's not alot. Deceleration pull can indicate a thrust angle that is off, which can be caused by a sheared centering pin. Have you measured distance right and left, center of front hub to center of rear hub? Most alignment shops ignore anything but front end adjustments on Jeeps.

Thrust angle:
align_thrustgif-1.jpg


Normally the "steering on a ball" symptom indicates caster wrong (yours looks good), or looseness in the steering intermediate shaft (yours checks OK).

Excessive power assist can aggravate issues, saginaw pumps can be shimmed for less assist but you'll have to find someone who knows his stuff to do that...

Measure rollout on your tires. Chalk the sidewall of each tire, and make a corresponding mark on the ground. Roll Jeep forward one revolution until the chalk on the sidewall is facing down again. Mark the ground. Measure distance between chalk marks on ground. repeat for each tire. All measurements should be almost the same.

I was thinking you had a locker in the rear and were driving on uneven roads. I've pulled lockers out of Jeeps that the sales department couldn't sell because of pulling left then right on test drives. We have very uneven road surfaces here- weather extremes and studded tires make grooves in the pavement- if your track width is off, driving is a chore, but with a locker it's almost unsafe at times.

Randy, while my jeep is still in the shop, I went by yesterday and asked them to check the center pins on the rear axle. They did some research on possibly being a power assist problem with the pump but couldn't convince themselves that was an issue. Thanks for your questions and thoughts.
 
Have you tried removing the front track bar? This could be increasing your lateral stiffness and reducing your understeer. Removing it should increase your compliance and slow down your steering.
 
I know you are over this, hence the decision to sell.
Something looks strange with the front shackles. As Spieg mentioned the "bow-legged" look, but also from the side view it looks like the spring end of the shackles are angled way towards the front (may just be the camera angle)
Are the leaf springs the wider YJ ones (2-1/2") ? (they look like they are)
Also, again from the limited view of the photo, the upper shackle mount doesn't look like it's moved forward.
Do you know if they are new front mounts for wider shackles, and have been moved forward?
If the mounts are factory with wider shackles and the excess width is made up with bushings that could be a problem, not necessarily THE problem.
Just some random thoughts.
Don't give up.
(If it was me I'd want to find the solution and go back to the experts and teach them something. :evil:)
 
Just skimming through this. My prediction is that if and when the front ball joints were replaced, they were not done correctly. There is a very important and particular order in which you torque those things down. If done incorrectly it will produce symptoms exactly as you describe.

Don't want to contribute anything unwelcomed, but that's my theory and I'll stick to it until proven otherwise. It's a shame to sell if it is something so incredibly simple to fix.
 
WalkerHound has a good suggestion....

Honestly, there are only so many parts in this steering system, and you've covered them all... at least ONE of them HAS to be set up incorrectly!

As much of a PITA it may be, it might be a good idea put the frame on jack stands and completely remove the axles, leaf springs, and spring hangers... then inspect each part and slowly put it back together, ensuring proper specs and installation. There's a problem in there somewhere, and your local shops don't seem to want to dig deep enough to find it.

At the risk of sounding like a total d*ck, I'd like to point out that you're advertising a Jeep in "beautiful and extremely solid" condition, even though it has a known safety issue which is not disclosed in the ad (even though it is disclosed here on the forums). That's quite a liability.

One way or another, this issue will need to be addressed. If you solved the steering problem, would you still want to sell the Jeep?

Another question (which I'm sure you've already considered): did this Jeep have bad steering when you bought it, or did it show up after a series of modifications?

Like most of us who have contributed to this thread, my curiosity is piqued... and I'd sure like to know how it turns out!

Good luck! :)
 
I'm sitting on the edge of my seat waiting to hear if anything has come of the last "fixes". Being interested in buying your jeep makes me even more interested in a resolution to this. I for one would not feel comfortable taking my family to the lake in a jeep that had issues like this.
I don't know much about jeeps and even less about mechanical engineering but what about changing the length of the Pitman Arm? If everything is tight and/or has been replaced wouldn't it reason that a ratio is off in the system? If the ratio is correct within the steering box and if the wheel turn correlates properly to steer shaft wouldn't a longer Pitman arm be the only thing else to change the ratio as it relates to steering wheel input to front wheel output?
I might be way off but I thought I'd shoot my 2 pennies at it being that I might have a vested interest in the outcome.
 
I have faced this over steer problem twice on my Scout2. Once it was a caster angle problem and the other was not enough toe in.
 
WalkerHound has a good suggestion....

Honestly, there are only so many parts in this steering system, and you've covered them all... at least ONE of them HAS to be set up incorrectly!

As much of a PITA it may be, it might be a good idea put the frame on jack stands and completely remove the axles, leaf springs, and spring hangers... then inspect each part and slowly put it back together, ensuring proper specs and installation. There's a problem in there somewhere, and your local shops don't seem to want to dig deep enough to find it.

At the risk of sounding like a total d*ck, I'd like to point out that you're advertising a Jeep in "beautiful and extremely solid" condition, even though it has a known safety issue which is not disclosed in the ad (even though it is disclosed here on the forums). That's quite a liability.

One way or another, this issue will need to be addressed. If you solved the steering problem, would you still want to sell the Jeep?

Another question (which I'm sure you've already considered): did this Jeep have bad steering when you bought it, or did it show up after a series of modifications?

Like most of us who have contributed to this thread, my curiosity is piqued... and I'd sure like to know how it turns out!

Good luck! :)

I understand what you are saying, and obviously when someone drives the jeep, they either notice the oversteer or they don't. I've had 6 CJs and this one steers the worst. The owner of the jeep shop that's been doing the work has a CJ he's named "Sketchy" because of the steering. He thinks mine is fine and I've had a number of other CJ owners tell me "that's how Jeeps drive".

I feel safe driving this jeep, I drive it almost daily on the highway at 65mph, but I'm just being a perfectionist and overly anal considering I've spent over $3500 on the steering alone. Maybe now it's just a mission
 
Have you tried removing the front track bar? This could be increasing your lateral stiffness and reducing your understeer. Removing it should increase your compliance and slow down your steering.

Front track bar has now been off for over 2 months.
 
Back
Top