Well I got it moving under its own power again. Both front leaf springs were bent and trashed, so I bought a replacement 2.5" lift kit from General Spring in Kansas City. Seem like well made springs for the price, much cheaper than anything else I could find, and came with poly bushings and all the U-bolts. Price is $279 before shipping:
http://www.generalspringkc.com/product_p/cj25.htm
Near as I can tell it sits very close to where it did with the Black Diamond 3" springs. It had Pro-Comp ES3000 shocks, but one of them got trashed in the wreck, so I'm using the cheapest Monroe gas shocks I could find. Rock-Auto had them on sale for $9/each, so it's worth experimenting. The ride "quality" with the Pro-Comps and Black Diamond springs was absolute garbage. I think a Conestoga wagon would be smoother. So I'm curious to see how the General Springs with cheapo Monroe shocks work.
In total I had to replace:
Spring hanger and shackle hanger, both of which I had spares for from parts Jeeps. Cost $0
Leaf springs. General Spring 2.5" springs (4) with U-bolts and poly bushings: $279
Rubber brake line, Rock Auto: $9
Hard brake line to left front from proportioning valve: $25 for a roll of 25' of copper-nickel-ferrous alloy brake line.
Left front fender: (had a spare) $0.
Tie rod: Omix-Ada with both TRE's from Amazon.com: $65
So this accident cost me a total of around $375 but the Jeep is going to come out better than it was before.