How not to cross a river in a CJ-8 (or anything)

Moabite

CJ-8 Member
CJ-8.com Member
City
Moab
State
UT
#21
While one of the IKs would have been faster and more maneuveable, the raft might have been a more stable platform to reach the guy and perhaps even pull him in. Stay upstream from the Jeep and there is VERY little danger in that situation on the Dolores. I saw no rapids in the video. At least get out there and assess the possibilities and risk rather than stand around and jeer. Grand County SAR would spend the entire river season searching for bodies in the river if people were not willing to take some risk and rescue others in trouble. Rescues have been happening many times every day on The Daily stretch of the river above Moab during this season's very high water. We are most often never even called, though we do hear about some of them.
 

bigwalton

Picture cravin' AK Postal nut
Staff member
SOA Member
City
Dexter
State
MI
#22
While one of the IKs would have been faster and more maneuveable, the raft might have been a more stable platform to reach the guy and perhaps even pull him in. Stay upstream from the Jeep and there is VERY little danger in that situation on the Dolores. I saw no rapids in the video. At least get out there and assess the possibilities and risk rather than stand around and jeer. Grand County SAR would spend the entire river season searching for bodies in the river if people were not willing to take some risk and rescue others in trouble. Rescues have been happening many times every day on The Daily stretch of the river above Moab during this season's very high water. We are most often never even called, though we do hear about some of them.
Great that’s true but my point still stands. The speed of that water, my boating knowledge and having absolutely no clue what’s around the bend that’s just a couple hundred yards away would have kept me right there.

If I was you and or had been on that water before, absolutely, but I won’t generically blame these people with no knowledge of their skill or ability :shrug:

As an example, without rescue training how could anyone know what you said about little risk if you stay upstream? That the raft would be preferable to the kayak (not doubting you but almost seems counterintuitive from a maneuverability perspective to my unskilled self)?

What if the dude couldn’t swim, panicked and jumped onto an unskilled kayaker, capsizing them both? Then what if there’s rapids around that bend?

If you think you can help, help no question, but I’m still of the “don’t compound a bad situation if you have no clue” thinking and we don’t know anything about these boaters.
 
Last edited:

don87401

Scrambler Junkie
LIFETIME
CJ-8.com Member
SOA Member
City
Farmington
State
NM
#23
After the Jeep stopped and if I could help get him out of the Jeep, yes I would be glad to launch a boat and ferry across the river to aid in that but I would not have just chased the stuff going down the river. Or if he had been washed out of the Jeep I would have been in a boat and after him.
 
Last edited:

Belizeit

CJ-8 Member
CJ-8.com Member
City
River Ridge
State
La
#24
To me it is 2 particular things that jump out. (1). If you can't swim well, what are you doing driving out in the middle of a river. (2). Never drive ANY vehicle into a fast moving stream or river that could be deeper than 18 inches of water because your vehicle will get swepted away. The final thing is unless you have 4 people paddling that raft you would be swept down river before you got across this river to the scrambler to make a rescue. I've been a strong swimmer all my life but with jeans and shoes that is very dangerous trying to get rescued or rescuing someone.
 

Moabite

CJ-8 Member
CJ-8.com Member
City
Moab
State
UT
#25
The final thing is unless you have 4 people paddling that raft you would be swept down river before you got across this river to the scrambler to make a rescue.
We can play "What if" games all day. After listening to the video more carefully, you at least hear one of the girls talk about getting "one of the duckies" or the "double duckie" (their inflatable kayaks) to go after the guy. At least someone in the party was trying to figure out how to help. The moron with the camera does nothing but profanely deride someone who is in a difficult and perhaps dangerous situation. The raft was a rowing rig...not a paddle boat. Anyone with average river skills in one of the IKs or one person with a passenger in the raft could have easily ferried across the river and still been well upstream of the Jeep...with the passenger pulling the Jeeper into the boat or at least throwing him some flotation or a life jacket. The raft would definitely have been the better platform. If they aren't that good or strong at maneuvering their boat, they have no business being on the Dolores, which is flowing well above average for this time of year. And I'd be extremely surprised if there was any person in the boating party who was not aware of what was "around the bend."

One of the things you learn in the rescue business is that seconds often count. The moron on the cell phone seemed more interested in getting his next viral video than in trying to decide if he (or anyone nearby) were even capable of helping. It's irrelevant if the guy is a total neophyte or an experienced river guide. He never even considers trying to rally help. Not helping someone in danger because you are incapable of doing so or because it is too dangerous is one thing. Not even considering some type of attempt is inexcusable. There was a piece on the local TV news within the past week about an accident where no one stepped up to help the victims. Everyone stood around taking cell phone videos until an ambulance arrived. Sad, but true.

And FYI...if you try to drive across the Dolores at the normal crossings just upstream from the Colorado near Moab, don't do it if the water is above, if I remember right, about 500 cfs...or maybe it is 300 cfs. The figure is written on one of our maps on the wall of the SAR building. If anyone needs to know, I can check next time I go to town. The Dolores is currently running over 3200 cfs. Check the flow at the Cisco/Dewey station: Dolores river at Dewey
 
Last edited:

Belizeit

CJ-8 Member
CJ-8.com Member
City
River Ridge
State
La
#26
I used one of those rafts with a good friend for 3 days on the John Day river in Oregon just a few years ago and you can control them pretty well going down river slower than the current, but going straight across or upriver is pretty futile with that type of current. 500 cfs is not much water. The river that is about 600 ft from my front door has been at flood stage for about 4 months now at about 1,250,000 cfs. :)
 

Moabite

CJ-8 Member
CJ-8.com Member
City
Moab
State
UT
#27
I used one of those rafts with a good friend for 3 days on the John Day river in Oregon just a few years ago and you can control them pretty well going down river slower than the current, but going straight across or upriver is pretty futile with that type of current. :)
Respectfully, that is just not true. Or perhaps I should say it depends on the river. On a river such as the Dolores at the current flow, it is not hard to ferry across and not be that far downstream when you reach the other side. Yes, it takes effort and you have to know the proper angle to take. It is simple in flat water...and the Jeep was crossing in flat water...and the Dolores is a narrow river. I have been lucky enough to have spent months and months and months (perhaps years) on the Colorado and Green Rivers in rowing rigs, including two 35-day private trips through the Grand Canyon, numerous 7-10-day Cataract Canyon and Westwater trips, and hundreds of trips down the Daily stretch of the Colorado upstream from Moab. Ferry angles are one of the things we teach our SAR members if they do not already have that skill. We just finished teaching ferry angles on the Colorado which was running 40,000 cfs a couple of weeks ago...down to a bit over 30K now but still more than double the average flow for July 2. Gradient actually plays more of a role in water speed than cfs. If you are on any river, ferrying should be a skill you need to have.
 
Last edited:

Belizeit

CJ-8 Member
CJ-8.com Member
City
River Ridge
State
La
#28
I have that skill. Grew up on the Rouge River in Oregon 50 years ago. But you are talking about professionals on the river, and those people on the banks and in the river are not that, they proved that the first minute of that video. Gradient actually does not matter always, it depends on the river. The river outside my door is actually 8 ft below sea level and flat as can be and the current is probably at least 12 mph, it's the quantity and volume upriver creating the speed. Just saying
 

ag4ever

Average Nut
LIFETIME
CJ-8.com Member
City
Richmond
State
TX
#29
The cross sectional area plays a much larger role in determining water velocity of a river when discussing cfm flow rates. If the 2 rivers have the same cross sectional area, then gradient comes into play.

You can flow a lot more water through a 100’ diameter pipe than a 6” diameter pipe. The speed of the water could be the same, but the cfm would not.

In the end, I think this is an example of what NOT to do in a Jeep AND on the shore when witnessing an incident like this.
 

Belizeit

CJ-8 Member
CJ-8.com Member
City
River Ridge
State
La
#32
No they are not, on the high seas it's a whole other mater. At the time this one had the potential highest value of a salvage operation. NASA External Fuel tank for the space shuttle out in the Gulf of Mexico in 1995. image.png
 

walkerhoundvm

Typical Know-it-all
LIFETIME
CJ-8.com Member
City
Cave Creek
State
AZ
#33
I have nothing interesting to add, but I went up to telluride this morning (after staying in canyonlands last night) and the San Miguel was flowing pretty damn quick. I'm staying with relatives on the Arkansas near Canon city tonight and tomorrow and it's impressive, but not as high as it was a couple weeks ago. I guess Colorado got a little more snow this year or something. What'd they say, like 600% snowpack or something? Wow.

E - I also think it's borderline criminal to sit there and videotape something like this without even so much as throwing a life jacket. We're arguing over physics and geography and there's a guy in the river who could've flipped and gone under. A person, who may have done something stupid and almost killed himself; every one of us for sure has done something like that, what'd we think if that was all captured on video with some guy laughing. Would you rather be "that guy on the video laughing" or "that guy on video who dropped his camera and sprang up to help."

I think collectively we've started losing compassion for our fellow man.
 
Last edited:

OGRES

Legacy Registered User
LIFETIME
City
Suwanee
State
GA
#34
I have nothing interesting to add, but I went up to telluride this morning (after staying in canyonlands last night) and the San Miguel was flowing pretty damn quick. I'm staying with relatives on the Arkansas near Canon city tonight and tomorrow and it's impressive, but not as high as it was a couple weeks ago. I guess Colorado got a little more snow this year or something. What'd they say, like 600% snowpack or something? Wow.

E - I also think it's borderline criminal to sit there and videotape something like this without even so much as throwing a life jacket. We're arguing over physics and geography and there's a guy in the river who could've flipped and gone under. A person, who may have done something stupid and almost killed himself; every one of us for sure has done something like that, what'd we think if that was all captured on video with some guy laughing. Would you rather be "that guy on the video laughing" or "that guy on video who dropped his camera and sprang up to help."

I think collectively we've started losing compassion for our fellow man.
I have completely lost compassion for people voluntarily doing stupid things putting themselves into danger.
 
Top