You really have 2 options and in some cases you can combine them.
1. Streamers (Roku, Apple TV, Amazon Fire TV, Xbox One)
Apple TV
I own/have owned all of these. If you're an iTunes user then the Apple TV is the way to go, the content library is huge and you have access to Hulu, Amazon & Netflix (and Plex with help for local media). That said, the Apple TV interface is not great and the video quality on iTunes content isn't the BEST. You can buy "Season Pass" content through iTunes for shows that need to stay caught up with. For example, a season of Breaking Bad may have been $30 and you'll receive the shows almost as soon as they air on TV. That may sound like a lot but you can re-watch them forever and if you really only watch 2 or 3 network shows then you're paying for the entire year with one month worth of DTV/Time Warner cost.
Roku
The Roku is great and they do have the largest library of 3rd party channels. Now, most of those channels are worthless but there are a few goodies in there. If you're a UFC fan then you can get PPV UFC fights through your Roku. They also have great cooking channels for the wife. I personally have owned the Roku and ditched it for the much faster Amazon Fire TV. The Roku suffers from a pretty sluggish interface and long buffering times when using Plex. Roku does have a great search feature that looks through Netflix, Amazon, Hulu and finds whatever you're looking for regardless of the provider. This is really nice since each service has exclusive rights to certain content and it can be difficult to remember each.
Amazon Fire TV
The latest and greatest of the streamers. 4x the processing power and ram of the others and it shows. The menu's are super snappy and the streams start almost instantly. My only con with the Fire TV is that they force the Amazon content as the primary view and then all other content (Netflix, Hulu, Plex, etc.) shows up as "Apps". Keep in mind that they just launched and will probably make quite a few user enhancements over the next 6 months. Amazon also offers voice search which only works on Hulu and Amazon content currently but the other apps should be able to pick up the functionality through their API.
Xbox One
As soon as they launch a Plex app, I will ship the Fire TV to mom and exclusively use the Xbox One. The interface is solid, it features voice commands without ever touching the remote (works better without screaming children in the house) and supports most of the content that the other streams do. The absolute coolest feature is that the Xbox One has HDMI input as well as output so using an HD antenna paired with a HW150PVR box, you can get all of your local HD channels mixed together with all of your streaming services. You can even use the Xbox One as a DVR to record over the air HD content from NBC, ABC, CW, Fox, CBS, etc. The ONLY downside is the lack of Plex which I do use quite a bit. On top of all the content streaming, and local TV channels, you can also play awesome games like Titanfall and do custom workout programs like P90x which will actually track your pushups and squats with the Kinect camera. It's pretty insane and a bit creepy at the same time.
2. Digital Antenna (UHF & VHF)
Just like in the xbox description, you can simply buy a good HD Antenna to get all of your local channels in crystal clear quality for free. If you pair it with a DVR then you can record and get past the crap commercials but this is probably the cheapest route. Amazon sells tons of great Antenna's, just make sure you get UHF and VHF to receive more content. You can also download an app called "TV Towers" (iPhone for sure, maybe Android) that will show you where the local towers are in relation to your house. It also gives you a compass to help point your Antenna in the right direction. Pretty sweet!
As the others have said, cable cutting is a great deal. You can get Amazon Prime, Netflix & Hulu for around $25 a month and have more content than you could ever watch. Additionally, you get Amazon prime which can drop jeep parts at your door in 2 days and believe me, they have a lot of parts! I even ordered x5 33" tires that came with free 2-day delivery. It's crazy!