• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Life of an Optima?

John N

Addicted....Ex-SOA VP
Lifetime Member
SOA Member
City
Rockville
State
VA
I was wondering what others are seeing as the "normal" life of an Optima battery. Mine won't hold much of a charge any more. It's a red top, about 6 year old, I think. If the Scrambler sits for more than a week, I have to charge the battery to get it to start. I only use a trickle charger set at 1 amp, so I do't fry any thing. There are a few constant draw items; the fi computer, clock and stereo.

I know it's time for a new battery for me. I figure a yellow top may be better this time.
 
6 years is pretty good. I usually got 5 to 6 with a sealed battery. The bad this is once it looses a cell, it's toast. I run duals and a 105 amp alt.
 
John N said:
I was wondering what others are seeing as the "normal" life of an Optima battery. Mine won't hold much of a charge any more. It's a red top, about 6 year old, I think. If the Scrambler sits for more than a week, I have to charge the battery to get it to start. I only use a trickle charger set at 1 amp, so I do't fry any thing. There are a few constant draw items; the fi computer, clock and stereo.

I know it's time for a new battery for me. I figure a yellow top may be better this time.

John,

I had one of the first series Optimas that were"guaranteed to Be the last battery you will ever buy" that lasted about 5 years. When I took it back they were going to pro-rate its remaining life/value until I pointed ouut the "lifetime guarantee" sticker. They gave me az new battery but no lifetime guarantee. Bottom line they are good batteries but not what they are hyped to be (no more lifetime guarantees offered).

BTW, allof mine have been yellow Optimas.
 
i bought my first one in 2004..and it is just now starting to show signs that its getting weak...i know my had a 5 year replacement warranty...10 year prorated...not sure what warranty that have now...i bought mine in charlottesville...that is how i can remember exactly when i got it.
 
I just had to replace a blue top after about 2 years. It would charge fully. I was very disappointed for a $175 battery.

Truck
 
Thought the blue tops were supposed to be the "ultimate" battery.
 
I've had great luck with Optimas. My primary reason for using them is the no-spill feature- as much as Jeeps bounce, acid is bound to start eating things. That never happens with an Optima. I figure the extra 75$ is worth it to keep the rust monster at bay.
 
The one in my pickup just died during the coldest days to date this year--not very opportune! Anyway, got about 5 years out of it I think which seemed pretty decent. Replaced it with a Batteries Plus unit and we'll see how it goes . . . .
 
I have heard from a number of sources that the biggest problem we have with our Jeeps is that the alternator was not wired correctly from the factory. The unit obtains a ground through the mounts and the sense wire runs directly to the output. If you run a nice dedicated ground and re-locate the sense wire to the starter solenoid the alternator will provide energy more accurately and is supposed to increase battery life. This all starts to boarder on things I can barely grasp...but it makes sense to me.
 
I've had a yellow top in the XJ for about 6 years, and it's beginning to get a bit tired. In the first year I left the interior lights on during a business trip. Killed the battery completely, but it charged back up (only time it's been charged). That vehicle has no constant draw.

I have another red top in a vehicle I just use to wheel (battery about 2 years old). It has a constant draw, and tends to run down if I do not disconnect the battery (even though I have the GM performance alternator producting a ton of juice). Just mentioned this to an electrician friend that has many wheelers and Optima batteries, and he contends that they maintain their life better if you give them a "hard" charge every now and then - enough to heat up the battery. Did this to this battery, and it is performing much better.

...for what it's worth :shrug:
 
I want to say that I have had a red top for my YJ since 03 and its held up well. Looks cool and functions prefectly, and when I got it it was like $99.99!!There were a coupla times it lost the charge form one thing or another, but slow charged well. Never really had it banging around much, but I would venture to say that its probably the best 4x4 off-roading type of battery out there.
That said, they do prorate your usage if there is a problem with it. I know its a stretch, but I have returned other lesser name batteries to "super" stores and had NO problem getting a new battery without any questions.
My point- is there is one- is that I think for the money you can get the same thing with a better warranty.... These OPTIMA things are too rich for my blood.
Not sure if it applies here either, but they have done studies on the reg. and lith. batteries for hand held applications, and the name brand and price are the only real differences. If anyone knows different from persoanl experience I am willing to listen.
 
Personally, I think they either slacked off on their QA process or changed the manufacturing process. My first red top came when I bought the first Scrambler in 2000. I was by no means new and I never had to recharge it, including three 6 month periods of non-use in a 3-year period and over 500 days of non-uses in another 2-year period. I replaced it in January 2007 because it started to slow down in the winter and I didn't want to get caught with a dead battery in the winter. I was so impressed with it's performance, I bought 2: one for my Grand National and one for the Scrambler.

This past winter I deployed again, when I came back, they were both dead. They replaced the Scrambler's Optima and said the Grand National's just needed a charge (which I already attempted). I ended up bringing back the Grand National's Optima and getting a Diehard Platinum when Sears finally accepted that it wasn't holding a charge. It took me 2 salespeople and a manager before I told them I would continue to return everyday that it failed, log my visits and continue up the chain. :angry:

In all honesty, I didn't want to buy anything else from Sears, but the Diehard is the best one going.
 
Last edited:
From what I can tell. Since Optima was bought out by Excide I believe, their quality has really gone down hill.

Seems like Deka and Odyssey batteries are better at this point in time.


Carl
 
To be acurate, this is my second Optima. The first one was replaced in it's first week, the current one is it's replacement. I guess I'll dig out the receipt and just see what, if anything, I can get under the warrenty.

I just want to stick with a battery that has no acid; I just think it's safer in the Jeep that way.
 
John,
I plan to replace mine with the Sears Platimun(sp?) / Odyssey. They are pricy but seem to have an excellant rep.
They are a gel type as well.
 
My first Optima battery was a blue top in a '96 Nissan hard body extended cab, 33's with 6 in lift. I had around $2300 worth of stereo in it including 2 12in Orion's in the back. I used to do shows with it and would crank the stereo all day get in it and start it right up with never even a hint of it going bad.

When my truck was stolen in '99 it was driven around for weeks with the ignition broken to the point it wouldn't turn off and stayed going that long. Once the battery went dead, finally I guess, it was stripped and dumped. Just like joker it had the life time on it so I traded it for a red top, very similar story getting that done.

Since then I've had 4 other red tops in other vehicles and have never had one last longer than 2 years before the trying to recharge them process starts. The one in my Jeep now has to be jumped every time it sits for a couple weeks or so.

I think they are not very good any more and its cheaper and makes more since to just buy a wal-mart Everlast Max (yellow) battery, they last pretty well and if it doesn't there is zero hassle, walk in with the bad one they take it and say grab another. With out having to go back every day and climb the chain.

I don't care for optimas any more myself.
 
Optima failure...

I just had a yellow top fail after about 4 years.....left me stranded in Pearsonville,Ca. Just quit, no hint, nothing. Just quit. Cost me 500+ bucks to get a new one via tow truck.... now running an Interstate.....:banghead: Gonna have to go duals.....
 
I found my original receipt. I bought this one 04/01, not a bad life to get out of a battery. There was no sticker indicating what the warrenty was on it, so no "Lifetime" replacement. I bought a yellow top at Sam's Club. The warrenty is pretty poor, though, 1 year replacement/3 year pro-rated. The red top has a much better warrenty, 3 year replacement/72 month pro-rated; probably should have bought that.
 
Back
Top