• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Ox vs ARB or what other?

Major Jack

Legacy Registered User
City
Zillah
State
Wa
Spent the evening researching remote activated lockers. Seems the Ox or ARB come to the top. Though, I kept finding where some were pulling their ARB'S because of failure of o-rings and oil getting into air lines and not allowing activation.

Would be going into the front. Will be installing a Detroit locker in rear with 4:56's. Or, is this a good idea? 30" tires and 999 automatic. Does this sound like the right gears?

I value what you guys have to say. Please give me the pros and the cons.
 
failed o-rings in ARBs are usually because they were not installed properly. usually

personally, I would go with ARB. from what i've read, the OX cables are expensive (unless that has changed) to replace.
 
Never looked into these, but I always liked OX with a mechanical linkage. There's also the new electronic ones too, right? Ected or something?

On the gears, 4.56 sounds low to me, especially with the 999 (no overdrive), with 30" tires. You'll be doing street driving in this right? Assume that's why you want the selectable in front. Look for some gear calculators, Randy's ring and pinion has a good one and play with the numbers. 3.73 or 4.10 sound better to me without actually looking anything up.
 
4.56's and 30" sounds a little low to me too. I'm thinking 4.10 also...

The electric lockers fascinated me too, to the point that I bought a pair of Ecteds. Internet searches will give as much positive as negative on anything. The Ecteds are a limited slip, then a locker. Ox and ARB are open, then locked. There are a couple other electric lockers too that are open, then locked. E-Locker comes to mind. My take- wires are a lot easier to run and repair versus cables or air lines.
 
Going on 13 years with my ARB in the back of my model 20 rear and I have only replaced the Orings once. The air line if properly run will stay out of harms way. The locker handles V8 power with ease and has not let me down.
 
my buddy has a electric locker in his front 60... always been a problem. he hates it.
 
I've had ARBs for about 6 years with only one minor issue, the o-ring gasket on the air compressor tank failed. I found that while I was in my garage, so it wasn't a big deal. ARB sent me 2 replacements for free (I wasn't under warrenty or even close). They've been good for me.
 
My question is why lockers and gears with only 30" tires. That kind of gear on the street will be horrible to drive without much larger tires. No top end at all maybe 45-50 mph. I have to assume with 30" you plan to stay on the street. Theres no where here to use lockers at that height. Also full detriot in the rear is a commitment to serious offroading. If youre not used to driving with one can be dangerous if you drive aggresively. The rear tends to load and unload during accelleration and decelleration. If you let off quickly in a curve you better have both hands on the wheel. To my way of thinking a selectable in the rear and a regular locker in the front. You dont need a locker on the street. Or 4wd for that matter. Then offroad lock in the front. A front locker makes a world of difference. Then you have the option of engaging the rear if needed. As far as lockers ive had a couple arbs, locright and detriot. No complaints with them. I know guys who are happy with the ox. I think my next may be the ected but have no need with what i currently have.
 
I had ARB's in my TJ. I bought them used and need several parts and shims when I installed them. I called ARB and they sent me everything I needed (and a bunch of stickers) for free. Some of the best customer service I've ever had!
 
I am in Alaska = lots of snow and ice for months on end. I need to get around safely. Sounds like the Detroit locker and 4:56 gears for the AMC 20 need to find a new home.

Did the chart thing - 3:73 or 3:91's with the 30" tires fell right in the middle of the RPM range. So, what I am hearing is a posi in the rear with a selector in the front. Is this correct?

I am installing this with the Warn Full Floating axle setup.
 
Sounds like you need to look into TruTracs front and rear. I don't think a locker on snow or ice would be the best solution. You wont get the wheel spin from the inside tire with TruTracs as you would from a locker, selectable or not. I have used TruTracs and they work great for a street driven vehicle.
 
30" tires and 4.56 will certainly have acceleration, probably too much so if you're running a 4 or 6. You will be like an old cj2, run out of breath at 40 mph. Not sure where you would wheel around Juneau, but if you are mainly onroad and hit the mountains just every now and then, I would run taller gears and LSD front and rear. This is the approach I'm taking with my postal; I'm keeping stock height and plan on 30" tires. This rig is intended for mostly street with mild weekend warrior stuff to the fishing hole.

I've got a rear Detroit, a Powerlok front (only because you couldn't get a Detroit for a D30 back in the day), 4:10's and usually run 31"s on a cj5, and I use 4wd during the winter on road systems; interior Alaska and have done so for years both with the jeeps and pickups. I wouldn't have a Detroit in a Model 20, I've broken the one-piecers enough without a locker. You do have to pay attention, but once you know your rig, Detroits and snow are not the kiss of death. Tire chains and Detroits, well, just point the rig where you want to go and don't pack the radiator with snow. You can sidehill badly with Detroits, so you'll have plan your approach a bit. With 4:10's, it accelerates easily, crawls and tows better, and since it's a jeep, I don't worry about top end. I built the rig for smileage, not mileage, don't even think about.
 
Ok I see where youre coming from. You just dont all 4 tires locked on ice. from my experience, on ice with all 4 you go downhill which ever direction that is at the time. Sideways and backwards at once is not fun. The full floating kit is that for the rear? The reason i ask, i had that setup in a renegade and was not happy. The rear hubs kept unlocking on me. At the time my 20 was open. So everytime a hub unlockled the rear axle was out of commision. Found out quickly on I-85 outside Atlanta. Running 75 or 80 in the fast lane when the pass. rear unlocked. Had to do some quick thinking to get out of heavy traffic. I ended up making spacers out of tubing to do away with the unlocking function of the hub.
 
We just put the Eaton E-locker in the CJ's front d60. it is super simple and worked great. it does not activate as quick as the arb but didn't require air lines. the previous d44 had a lockright in the front and didn't have any weird steering issues. the d60 had a detroit and was extremely tough to steer. even in two low. it was easier to shift the front in only and drive that way on the trail. running with full hydro steering would have fixed that but not with a streetable rig.

we are putting a e-locker in the wife's prorock d60 this next week.
 
Sawdoff "I ended up making spacers out of tubing to do away with the unlocking function of the hub."

Hubs unlocking on the Warn Full Floater is an issue. Did you have the hubs with the allan set screw?

I an interested in how you made the spacers and how they functioned? Might be something I need to make.
 
Back
Top