OK, here's the photo essay on the rear Metalcloak fenders. I went with the 6" flare to match the front, but I think 4" might have looked a bit better. I really need 37"s now...
The Metalcloaks are extremely well made and fit the base plates perfectly. Here you can see the baseplates clamped to the body and the fender sitting below.
As you can see the baseplates are designed for a stock CJ opening, which appears to be taller and narrower than the Scrambler. Mounting the fender with the baseplates aligned to the bottom of the body left the flare too high, IMHO, and because of the inner fender design, left a lot of unusable space.
This would be great if you cut out your inner fenders and needed the room for huge tires. Not part of my plans.
So, I continued looking for the best option. I found the position where I liked the looks and the fit:
That left me with a problem. There would be a LOT of the base plate that I would have to remove, and how do I fill the 5/16" gap caused by the raised body lip? Weld in a filler to the back of the plate, leaving 2 seams? Then I had an idea...do I really need the plate? I guess not!
Much better:
But, I still have that gap from the raised lip to deal with.
So, I cut off the mounting tabs:
Welded them back on with a 5/16" setback: