- City
- Dexter
- State
- MI
What a fantastic thread, you definitely get the BW seal of approval for picture posting, WELL DONE!!!

I don't think anyone can answer your existential owner's crisis on frame-off vs. just F*&% it and git er dun... I like the thinking though.
First and most importantly, you WILL hate yourself later if you ditch it and get an LJ/JK.
I'm not all that great as a case study because my wife (oh how happy I am to have married her) wanted to get a Rubicon LJ when her DD took a crap on us back in 2005, so I've had that to use for the top-down Jeep fix when doing things to the Postal (like the 4.0/AW4 swap last summer). But here's my story on the build philosophy.
Reading on forums like this made me go through a lot of thinking on what to do with mine. Mentally I made a list of facts/factors/wants/needs that would go into the build I would do:
-I was not likely to have a tow-rig or trailer anytime soon
-I did not have more than basic handtools, a few power tools, no welder/welding experience, no lift, no engine hoist, etc. etc.
-I was facing the very real prospect of having to move to a different state within a few years (sounds like your in this boat)
-I was limited (in the house at the time) to a two-car garage and a wife that wanted to be able to park inside most of the time
-We were looking to start a family and knew time would get short (oh boy howdy if I only knew!
)
-I'd never done all that much on vehicles myself and would be learning everything for the first time as I went along.
For me, all of that added up to a big NUH-UH on a frame off. Do I wish I had been able to do one, of course, who wouldn't? But, I've been able to keep the projects somewhat reasonable and just enjoy driving it.
I wanted something very capable, but also always capable of driving anywhere with my family in tow.
The one big thing for me was after I had my accident and the subsequent fixes/upgrades (https://www.cj-8.com/forum/showthread.php?t=10119). On the plus side, the settlement got me money that sped up my build, on the downside it put the Postal out of commission for 1 year, 2 months, and 29 days before it drove again. I love the upgrades that I ended up with out of the effort, but I got REAL tired of it not being together and running a couple times in there.
I think it's very possible to have an end goal in sight and just do things in a project fashion though. One thing you can do is look for used stuff as a step to get you closer and then sell them off when you want to go to something new to recoup the cost. I bought a used 4" lift knowing that one day I wanted to get a new lift kit, but the used set got me on bigger tires until I could do the new kit. My wreck killed me selling off the used lift, but that was the plan and I know I'd have gotten back what I paid for it.
Incrementalism will really bite you when you don't look to the end result and buy new stuff for each of the steps in the middle. Buying used and buying smart with an end goal can get you where you want to be, while keeping it drivable for long stretches and helps you learn along the way.
My $.02 anyway... I say get a plan, start looking for deals and build to what you want. You can always do the frame off later and hopefully by that time you're just fixing little things and reinstalling the good equipment you ended up with from the initial plan
PS. on the trailer, just look for one of these: https://www.cj-8.com/forum/showthread.php?t=20940, no fab needed. The thing I've read about "back-halving" a Jeep or truck is that you end up with way more frame than you need and it's overweight. Now doing a Jeep body on a trailer frame is about ideal, but with the old military trailers out there for the finding, why bother?

I don't think anyone can answer your existential owner's crisis on frame-off vs. just F*&% it and git er dun... I like the thinking though.
First and most importantly, you WILL hate yourself later if you ditch it and get an LJ/JK.
I'm not all that great as a case study because my wife (oh how happy I am to have married her) wanted to get a Rubicon LJ when her DD took a crap on us back in 2005, so I've had that to use for the top-down Jeep fix when doing things to the Postal (like the 4.0/AW4 swap last summer). But here's my story on the build philosophy.
Reading on forums like this made me go through a lot of thinking on what to do with mine. Mentally I made a list of facts/factors/wants/needs that would go into the build I would do:
-I was not likely to have a tow-rig or trailer anytime soon
-I did not have more than basic handtools, a few power tools, no welder/welding experience, no lift, no engine hoist, etc. etc.
-I was facing the very real prospect of having to move to a different state within a few years (sounds like your in this boat)
-I was limited (in the house at the time) to a two-car garage and a wife that wanted to be able to park inside most of the time
-We were looking to start a family and knew time would get short (oh boy howdy if I only knew!
)-I'd never done all that much on vehicles myself and would be learning everything for the first time as I went along.
For me, all of that added up to a big NUH-UH on a frame off. Do I wish I had been able to do one, of course, who wouldn't? But, I've been able to keep the projects somewhat reasonable and just enjoy driving it.
I wanted something very capable, but also always capable of driving anywhere with my family in tow.
The one big thing for me was after I had my accident and the subsequent fixes/upgrades (https://www.cj-8.com/forum/showthread.php?t=10119). On the plus side, the settlement got me money that sped up my build, on the downside it put the Postal out of commission for 1 year, 2 months, and 29 days before it drove again. I love the upgrades that I ended up with out of the effort, but I got REAL tired of it not being together and running a couple times in there.
I think it's very possible to have an end goal in sight and just do things in a project fashion though. One thing you can do is look for used stuff as a step to get you closer and then sell them off when you want to go to something new to recoup the cost. I bought a used 4" lift knowing that one day I wanted to get a new lift kit, but the used set got me on bigger tires until I could do the new kit. My wreck killed me selling off the used lift, but that was the plan and I know I'd have gotten back what I paid for it.
Incrementalism will really bite you when you don't look to the end result and buy new stuff for each of the steps in the middle. Buying used and buying smart with an end goal can get you where you want to be, while keeping it drivable for long stretches and helps you learn along the way.
My $.02 anyway... I say get a plan, start looking for deals and build to what you want. You can always do the frame off later and hopefully by that time you're just fixing little things and reinstalling the good equipment you ended up with from the initial plan
PS. on the trailer, just look for one of these: https://www.cj-8.com/forum/showthread.php?t=20940, no fab needed. The thing I've read about "back-halving" a Jeep or truck is that you end up with way more frame than you need and it's overweight. Now doing a Jeep body on a trailer frame is about ideal, but with the old military trailers out there for the finding, why bother?
Last edited:


I learned brakes on my Scrambler too. Good call on doing new parts, brakes and steering are the two places not to skimp.