People up here prefer Line-X, but we don't have a dealer in state anymore, so the only trucks that have it come up from the Lower 48.
I did Herculiner in my YJ tub that I put onto the CJ-7 (that eventually became my 8). (Since it was a galvanized YJ tub, I wasn't worried about "hiding" rust.) I really liked the Herculiner; in fact I liked it enough that I coated my center console with it, and undercoated my 8's rock-rails and front fenders. I did have it rub through in a couple place, but the first was because I had hauled a Dana 44 housing 700 miles, and the other place was where my speakers were constantly bouncing around on a corner of the rear fenderwells. I also did it over the rails down to the edge of the vertical panel and had zero regrets; I didn't find it interfered with either my hard top of my BesTop Supertop. The other advantage for Herculiner/DIY is that you can touch it up! It does, however, feel like sandpaper against your skin, unless you don't stir the rubber bits into the mixture. I intentionally avoided the rubber bits when I coated my center console and it came out smooth (but I wasted half the can that had the rubber bits). The most important thing for Herculiner is the prep! You must be anal with prep for it to adhere properly.
For my 8, I wanted a professional job, and ended up with Rhino. (Since my 8 isn't really an 8, and it has an aluminum tub, I didn't feel bad about it.) They have a couple different products now, and I went with the softer one. It doesn't have a painful texture at all. I had them spray both the inside and bottom, and specified places where I wanted it a little thicker. I'm happy with how it turned out.