• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

What's the best repro tub and why?

What's the best repro tub?

  • Aluminum

    Votes: 50 36.8%
  • Steel

    Votes: 74 54.4%
  • Fiberglass

    Votes: 9 6.6%
  • Kevlar

    Votes: 3 2.2%

  • Total voters
    136

Petybin

Basic User
Hi Guys,

Can you give me advice on what is the best kind of repro tub for the Scrambler and why? What's the low down on Aluminum tubs, Steel tubs and Fiberglass tubs? And who are the best manufacturers.

Pet:confused: :p
 
ALUMINUM

I voted for the alum. won't rust and the body is much thicker than the stock steel body-JC
 
I have seen several of the JP aluminum bodies....I wouldn't go any other way-they're first class!
 
How much do Aluminum tubs go for?;)

Are they a dead match with the original specs?

Aren't the steel tubs more authentic?

Pardon the ignorance:rolleyes:

Pete
 
I have examined aluminum and fiberglass. If I ever saw a steel replacement body, I didn't know it.

I agree the JP aluminum tubs are first class but they are not a dead match. I do not believe any of them are including steel. Mainly, I believe the Jeep logo on the front quarter panel is missing on even the new steel bodies and replacement panels. It is a matter of copyright infringements.

The JP people are on the West Coast and show up at vendor events such as SEMA and EJS with a display of their products. They have ads in all the 4wd mags. You might contact them and see where they will have a show that you might be able to attend or who is a dealer or customer in your area that might have a body that you can examine. There is one right here in NE Kansas so surely you can find one in CA.

The things I noticed about the JP body for a CJ8 that was not a dead match were all internal and included the boxed area in front and behind the doors, the floor contours, the seat mounts, the dash, and the firewall. A casual observer on the outside would never know it was not original unless they noticed the missing logo on the front quarter panel.

Later, Ken
 
I have two steel tubs I bought from collins bros jeep in Texas a few years back.

The only reason I went with steel was I needed to swap the firewall to retain right hand drive. I also decked the rear for a CJ-7 top. The mods are easy to do on steel.

If I had to do it again I would go with JP and aluminum. They can do custom work for a price and they also make them full legnth or bobbed.
Here is their website..

www.jpoffroad.com


I would never go with fiberglass or kevlar. But living in Alaska I would be concerned about it getting brittle in sub-zero temps or the plywood rot on the inside they use between the layers of fiberglass.

Here is a photo of the "new" steel tub. I can shoot closeups if you want.

LOST
 
Depends on what you want

Somewhat close original Omix Ada, especially when they start making them with JEEP stamped. Though they like to rust.

Driver/offroad etc. Aluminum, no one will ever mistake it for an original tub but it is tough, strong, and wont rust.
 
Jimbob said:
Depends on what you want.

I agree with Jimbob. I don't think there's any one "right" answer. There are tradeoffs all around.

Some things to consider, IMO:
1) Intended use - Daily driver vs. rock crawler vs. show rig vs. somewhere in between.

2) Budget - Fiberglass bodies are available for ~$1700 vs. JP aluminum @ $2850 vs. steel tubs at ~$3000 (I believe); prices don't include shipping. That's a pretty sizable difference, and the money may be better spent on another part of your project.

3) Qualified repair specialists - Are there people in your area who can repair any of the respective materials in the case of an accident. Steel is a no-brainer, but fiberglass and especially aluminum are considerations.

4) Climate - Someone mentioned the extreme cold with fiberglass. It's a valid consideration. Another consideration would be very damp, wet areas (or salty ones) that may lead to accelerated corrosion of steel.

5) Is bobbing your rig down the road a consideration? If so, fiberglass might not be a good choice, although maybe it's possible.

I personally plan to go with a 4WD Hardware fiberglass tub. The price is right for me. I intend to use it as a fair-weather daily driver with some offroad (probably mild, considering some of the stuff I have seen other people here tackle). There's also a local shop that has been dealing 4WDH bodies for 20 years, and they have a lot of experience with and helpful tips for installation.

Well, I guess that's my $.02.

Craig
 
Last edited:
I'm sort of concerned with maintaining the originality of my CJ8. I'd want to get it as close to original as possible so that the resale value would be higher. I'm considering the tubs from Omix-ada or Willys Overland. I'm thinking ... if the original was steel, then mine's gotta be steel too.
I heard that all the steel tubs come from the same company from the Philippines and that they just distribute it among different dealers.:cool:
Can anybody tell me the problems of the steel tubs? (aside from rust):D
 
I understand and somewhat agree with you even though I wrote the positive response on the JP tub.

There is a posting from several months ago where someone with experience with Willys Overland discussed their experience with them. It was very positive. What you say about OmixAda (the Philipines stamper) I believe true also. What WO does as I remember is take the OmixAda tubs and does a lot of fitting and tweaking to them before shipping them to customers. The earlier posting describes some of that fitting and tweaking and that may give you an idea of what you are in for if you buy an OmixAda tub from someone other that WO.

You might do a search under this heading for Willys and see if you can find it.

The lowest price place I have heard of for purchasing OmixAda items is John Krage at http://www.jeepdoc.com/zshowcase.asp even though he doesn't list the CJ8 tub in his catalog, I believe he will get it for you. I have seen the floor board he sells for $189 go for over $300 like at Raybucks - same parts #.

The OmixAda website is http://www.omix-ada.com/index.html and it lists most of their distributors.

You might also just go way back under this heading to see all the discussions that have gone on over time on replacement panels and tubs.

Later, Ken
 
Upon further research, I learned that Omix-ada gets their stuff from Mdjuan from the Philippines. Check out www.mdjuan.com.ph
It seems these are the guys that stamp the steel tubs.
I'll try to find out what they say about these steel tubs in past threads. Thanks for the advice:D
 
:cool:

First I have a Bobbed JP Pff-Road aluminum Tub.

I am not bulding a perfect rebuilt CJ-8, I am building a long wheel based Jeep to be driven daily and used for off-road travel.

I found the aluminum body to be rugged but light in weight, formed in all respects to a CJ-8 that I was interested in.

I have after market heater, seat bracket, full roll cage, tailgate, hood and home made tail-lights, and mod'd full top.

as you can see everything I have done isa fitted item anyway so a true repo body was not what I wanted.

I would recommend the JP Off-Road body for a great looking Jeep as long as you don't want a perfectly repoduced Scrambler, just a Scrambler that will draw attention.

Luck,
 
Last edited:
I vote steel

I just received my new CJ-8 tub from WO motors last week, and I am very happy with it. It is as solid as my original and it looks as close to the original as you would expect.

I didn't go fiberglass because I've noticed that the re-sale value seems to be a bit lower on these. Also, I've heard some complaints about fit up. A friend of mine got fiberglass wind shield and hood, and in my opinion they weren't worth a darn.

The aluminum bodies definately have some advantages (corrossion resistance, lightweight, strong), but Al is somewhat dificult to paint (I've seen some people just polish it up and go naked!) and you can encounter some cathodic/anodic issues between your steel parts and Al parts. Also, because they don't use stamps to build them, they will not look original.

Omix-Ada is the American front for the steel bodies that are stamped out in the Philipines. I haven't found anyone who makes a steel body except these people. All of the steel bodies that you see for sale are made by these people. WO Motors does some work to make it more compatible to original. I can't really say how much work they do, and is the extra couple $$ that they charge worth it. The problem is, I didn't see the tub before their modifications. I am very happy with what I have right now, although I haven't actually started with fit up.

To answer the question of increased rusting: If you paint it properly, it won't rust. Take a look at my original '81 tub. It's a major rust bucket. I am planning to powder coat the entire tub for increased resistance to scratches and a really good looking finish. Check out this previous thread....

http://forums.cj-8.com/showthread.php?s=&threadid=5556
 
lauminum tub scrambler

I've got a JP tub which I am using basically as a replacement for a rotted stock tub--more street use than anything. After a lot of research, I ruled out fiberglass, which cracks fairly easily (the people at Shell Valley shared that with me). At about the same prices as OW steel, I preferred the aluminum as rust is a huge problem up here in Chicagoland. But you get a tub with no holes drilled in it and you will spend countless hours measuring and drilling to remount your original systems (eg., heat and ventilation, brakes/pedals, steering column, body mounts). Mine reuses these stock part and is t hus labor intensive, though occasionally a lack of predrilled holes is an advantage--for example with a custom booster and master cylinder set up I have.

The dimensions are quite good, so if you take your time and be careful you can make it come together. As a point of information, these tubs are made in Canada by a company called Aqualu or Aqualo, not JP Offroad. They also make Land Cruiser bodies. I am making my own fenders, hood, and door overlays to get an all-aluminum appearance. JP sells fenders, but they are not exact copies and they go for $500 a pair--I'll pass. I found a good aluminum supplier and they got me every thing I need to make my own.

A final note: After I bought my tub, I saw that Matkins (the frame people) we advertising a heavier aluminum tub that was supposedly pre drilled (and cheaper!). I would have seriously considered that, though why you would need anything heavier duty than the JP tub is beyond me--it is a very tough unit.

Good luck,

Rich
 
tubs

I read somewhere that somebody is coming out with a plastic tub,not fiberglass or kevlar, but plastic.Some type of poly, something or another.
 
Re: tubs

Ted Wendel said:
I read somewhere that somebody is coming out with a plastic tub,not fiberglass or kevlar, but plastic.Some type of poly, something or another.

Matkins Extreme was going to offer a poly body, but something fell through with the deal. When I inquired about their aluminum bodies, they told me that the poly bodies (mentioned on their website) weren't going to be offered.

Not sure if this is the same company you were referring to or not.

Craig
 
Petybin said:
How much do Aluminum tubs go for?;)

Are they a dead match with the original specs?

Aren't the steel tubs more authentic?

Pardon the ignorance:rolleyes:

Pete

:cool:
Q) Are they a dead match with the original specs?

A) As close as any you will find. There was a write-up in one of the Off-Road Magizines about the swap of an aluminum tub for a steel one.
Looks great.
I just put my swing petals in place, fit perfectly, I installed a Dual Diaphram Brake booster and had to move the Clutch Master over 1 1/2" all mod instructions worked OK.

Q) Aren't the steel tubs more authentic?

A) Proably but what are you going after ?

Q) Pardon the ignorance:rolleyes:

A) What ignorance, we all ask questions. The thing is you are asking instead of just jumping off and screwing up, I like that.

OK, so how are you doing with the Tub thing ?
Have you decided yet what you are going to do ?

I still am voting for the aluminum, if you were around Boston I would suggest you visit me and see.

Later and good luck on the project.
 
NF,

Do you have aluminum? If you do I would love to see it. I'm going to be in Boston next week.

Truck
 
Back
Top