Jimbob said:
Depends on what you want.
I agree with Jimbob. I don't think there's any one "right" answer. There are tradeoffs all around.
Some things to consider, IMO:
1) Intended use - Daily driver vs. rock crawler vs. show rig vs. somewhere in between.
2) Budget - Fiberglass bodies are available for ~$1700 vs. JP aluminum @ $2850 vs. steel tubs at ~$3000 (I believe); prices don't include shipping. That's a pretty sizable difference, and the money may be better spent on another part of your project.
3) Qualified repair specialists - Are there people in your area who can repair any of the respective materials in the case of an accident. Steel is a no-brainer, but fiberglass and especially aluminum are considerations.
4) Climate - Someone mentioned the extreme cold with fiberglass. It's a valid consideration. Another consideration would be very damp, wet areas (or salty ones) that may lead to accelerated corrosion of steel.
5) Is bobbing your rig down the road a consideration? If so, fiberglass might not be a good choice, although maybe it's possible.
I personally plan to go with a 4WD Hardware fiberglass tub. The price is right for me. I intend to use it as a fair-weather daily driver with some offroad (probably mild, considering some of the stuff I have seen other people here tackle). There's also a local shop that has been dealing 4WDH bodies for 20 years, and they have a lot of experience with and helpful tips for installation.
Well, I guess that's my $.02.
Craig