• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

My De-Rustification Project

That's good. With no signs of corrosion or pitting, you're in good shape. Just getting them tightened up should make a world of difference! :thumbsup:
 
So it has been a while and what I did add got killed so I am bringing this back to life now that I am planning a swap to a tf 999 auto tyranny. I am assembling parts now and hope to do the swap over the winter. But a POS impala seems to be taking all of my cash.

I still need to get the knockdown linkage, the cooler and the lines. Oh and the driveshafts needed once done. Seems like I still need a lot. Ugh.
 
So it has been a while and what I did add got killed so I am bringing this back to life now that I am planning a swap to a tf 999 auto tyranny. I am assembling parts now and hope to do the swap over the winter. But a POS impala seems to be taking all of my cash.

I still need to get the knockdown linkage, the cooler and the lines. Oh and the driveshafts needed once done. Seems like I still need a lot. Ugh.

Are you wanting stock kick down linkage? If so I have probably 90% of it sitting in my garage. Let me know.
 
So, I just wrote a ton and I think it got deleted before posting. Fun. Here it goes again, but with less words.

I was working on the tf999 I got to put in the Scrambler and found out that the detent ball is too far out in the shaft not allowing the detent comb to move to the other gears.

While contemplating that mess, I headed down to Jim's Chop Shop tp take him some parts. I got 20 minutes in when I had shuddering and loud banging in the engine bay. I was doing about 65. I pulled off and went back home via some back roads that kept the speed down. Still making noise, but not as bad.

Pulled the valve cover off and the lifters look good and functional. I do need an exhaust header gasket, but otherwise it sounded OK tonight. But I have started to get blow by, and I was down over a quart of oil after just doing an oil change 2 weeks ago.

So I think I am in the market for a new engine. If I want to stay AMC, and look for a V8, what do you guys think I should go for? Remember I use this as a DD. I have looked at the 4.0/aw4s from Cherokees, so I am not opposed to that. Just am not sure I want to go with a third 258 if I will end up in the same situation in another couple of years. And I am budget minded right now. I will have 2 kids in college soon. But I also need to get this back on the road asap.

I am open to thoughts. I understand that getting a 258 will reuse a lot of what I have and save some $$, but that may not be best in the long run.

And I don't know if I want to go LS. That seems expensive.

Please Help!!!
 
I have a friend who's in a similar situation with his '83 CJ7.

I've advised him to rebuild the 258 (or get a rebuilt), and add a Howell TBI system to it. That's absolutely what I'd do!

An engine swap is a very time-consuming undertaking, and you'd be without your daily driver for quite a while (it could take months)!

If you can swing it, a 4.0 HO head on a 258 makes excellent torque! Keep the 258 lower end though... a full 4.0 swap leaves a little to be desired.

My Scrambler came with an SBC 350 already installed, so that's what I'm working with. But... if I had a 258, I'd stick with that engine!

Good luck! :cheers:
 
My favorite saying is every time I try to save $100 it ends up costing me $500. I know it's easy to look back and say this but a LS swap 3 engines ago is starting to look like the smart move now. Dain I feel for you my friend.
 
Honestly, I'd be looking for a cheap XJ or ZJ to buy to DD while you sort this out if you don't have another DD option. I would not rush this decision or the resulting install/swap to try to get it back on the road faster.

My thinking is that you find and buy a good XJ/ZJ for the money, use it as long as you need to make the -8 whole again and then sell the XJ for close to or what you paid for it so you're only out insurance and possibly a small difference that could be looked at as a rental fee.

Asking us for input between another 258, a 4.0/AW4, AMC 360 or LS is awfully broad. The biggest question is if you're trying to do it yourself with the tools available to you and doing a realistic assessment of what that means. Also, what's the inspection/emission regs going to require for you in NoVA? What you're able to put your hands on for the money is going to factor in huge as well. Willing to accept a used motor/trans? Would you want it to be new/reman? What about the trans?

A 4.0/AW4 swap is best if you have the donor vehicle sitting there to pull from as you go. Toby (mostly) and I pulled everything from a donor at Toby's and we went insane with all the random stuff we yanked off that XJ to have "just in case" we needed it. A lot of extra work that could have been avoided if I'd had the XJ here. That swap CAN be done in a weekend mechanically, the trick is how anal you want to be about the wiring, but I'd want to take longer and sort it out better. It's also hard to think about and buy every last thing you need for it (especially since CJOffroad and all those great threads went away) so it ends up being one of those nickel-and-dime deals with lots of trips to the part store, but I think that ends up being the case with any swap, really.

I'd have a very hard time putting money into another 258, personally. EFI or not (and EFI is not exactly cheap). However, that's what the Jeep is set up for now and would be the least work (even if you retrofit EFI, which I just did to Mater without a ton of trouble.)

Either an AMC 360 or LS gets into a more serious effort though not ALL that much more than the 4.0.

BTW, the forum auto-saves your last post. If it goes away for some reason there will be a "restore auto saved content" button below the compose window if you go back to that thread and hit "reply" again.
 
Dain,

Sorry to hear of your troubles. I don't care much for carbs. You can get a new FAST EFI (or many other brands) to retrofit previously carb'd vehicles for about 1200 (including fuel pump and everything). That isn't a bad option if you go AMC.

LS would be my choice, if there is room in the budget. Pick your flavor... 4.3 (v6) or the 4.8 or 5.3. They are plentiful and reasonably priced at salvage yards. However, the parts for the swap would likely be around 4-5K. Figuring 2500 for engine, trans, harness and computer. Then adding motor mounts, exhaust, hoses, shifters and either a transfer case and SYE, or adapter to the 300.

Another option is an older TBI GM power train. You can find complete running vehicles for half the price of an LS setup. I am planning on an 89 4.3 v6/700r4/np241C swap in my scrambler. That setup has a pretty solid jump in HP over the stock 258.
 
You've got lots of options as have been stated. You mentioned keeping it AMC. That makes most everything fit using stock parts. If you find a nice 304 or 360, then everything will bolt up without having to buy adapters and fabricate parts. This would be the less expensive way to get a V-8. And if you've got 1K for the total TBI set up (the only thing non-AMC you'll need), then you get the better mileage and easy startup for your DD.
 
There aren't any cheap 258's around you? I bought a used 258 with good compression a few years ago for $150, sold the A/C compressor, alternator, and bracket, the BBD, and the air cleaner off of it for $140, have a $10 motor.

I figure if I ever need an engine I can swap it in quickly, then rebuild my old motor on the stand, taking my time doing so.

Lupo doesn't have an extra motor around for sale?
 
There aren't any cheap 258's around you? I bought a used 258 with good compression a few years ago for $150, sold the A/C compressor, alternator, and bracket, the BBD, and the air cleaner off of it for $140, have a $10 motor.

I figure if I ever need an engine I can swap it in quickly, then rebuild my old motor on the stand, taking my time doing so.

Lupo doesn't have an extra motor around for sale?

This would be the only way that I'd do another 258, but it doesn't sit all that well with me given that you DD this. You could plan on rebuilding the spare to have ready for the next time or to swap back in when it's rebuilt, then hold onto the "good used" one as your spare. You could do this to get it running and then spend your money on an add-on EFI kit.
 
This would be the only way that I'd do another 258, but it doesn't sit all that well with me given that you DD this. You could plan on rebuilding the spare to have ready for the next time or to swap back in when it's rebuilt, then hold onto the "good used" one as your spare. You could do this to get it running and then spend your money on an add-on EFI kit.

:cool: I have a 258 with 75,000 sitting in a rust pile of a jeep that runs 2 hours away from you. We could drive it around but there's really no floor for the seat to sit on :crazy:
 
:cool: I have a 258 with 75,000 sitting in a rust pile of a jeep that runs 2 hours away from you. We could drive it around but there's really no floor for the seat to sit on :crazy:

:woot: Flinstone donor CJ FTW!
 
There's no secret that I'm in favor of a LS swap, I bought a 5.3L Vortec/4L60E engine and transmission out of a rolled 2005 truck and a 241C T/C for$2400. Everything else I needed came to another $3,000 plus Including the kit I bought from Advanced Adapters. I think if you have the 5K to spend that its the best way to go. I understand that shoes and clothes for the kids come before Jeeps sometimes.
 
:cool: I have a 258 with 75,000 sitting in a rust pile of a jeep that runs 2 hours away from you. We could drive it around but there's really no floor for the seat to sit on :crazy:

Problem solved :twocents:

With help from Dustin, y'all could swap engines in a day :rotfl::crazy::bacon::thumbsup::wave:
 
There you go! Bolt in, easy swap with no modifications required. Gets you on the road, and then you can figure out what you want to do long term.

Sometimes a quick patch is the best route to take.
 
Thanks guys. late to respond because work has had me by the short hairs all week. I was able to drive the JKU a few days, carpool one and work from home another. I took the Scrambler out for a drive last night and things seemed OK, so I took it to DC to work today. Rolled the dice. The exhaust leak is still there (obviously), and maybe some lifter noise. I will check my oil tomorrow and see if any went into the coolant.

As for a donor, my head is everywhere. I am leery of getting any used engine (I6 or v8) without knowing it runs, so that has me leaning toward Dustin's offer. It is much appreciated. Although the thing holding me back is that I have now been through two 258s. I am wondering if they are not made for my type of commute. either sitting in traffic stop and go for 2 hours each way or 1 hour at 2500 rpms at 65 MPH.

Stuff seems to break when I never have the cash (or I just never seem to have spare cash), so again, I am leaning toward Dustin's offer. I have seen a few 360s on CL the past few days (and Jim's Chop Shop has offered me a complete one), but I have no idea of their condition as they are from parts rigs. So, there is more dice rolling.

Decisions need to be made as I have wheeling plans this summer (and I still need this as a DD). Sounds like a trip to Dustin's is in order. But maybe I can limp this one along while I am arranging things.

Decisions ......
 
Back
Top