• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

How do you heat your shop?

Robert Slone

Legacy Registered User
City
Spring Hope
State
NC
Anyone have experience with electric heaters/blowers for heating smaller spaces. I'm going to build a shop 20' x 22' with 10' to the ceiling. The ceiling will be open to the rafters but the roof will be low. It will have R13 insulation.

It will be mostly for woodworking so open flame heat like wood, gas or kerosine is out. I'll need heat for short periods of time and it needs to heat up fast.

I saw a nice big drum fan/heater on wheels that would probably blow me out but it was over $750 :eek: . I've seen some smaller ones that mount on walls or ceilings for around $150 but I have to wonder if they'd do the job.

Anyone have any suggestions?
 
I built my workshop under my 3-car garage, so the garage is over heated space. the floor is warm enough all year round to lay on for working, and the garage never really gets below about 45 degrees even when it is 20 outside, so you can comfortably work in a heavy sweatshirt. Probably isn't practical for you to implement this solution though, hard to dig the hole for the basement after the garage is built :-) Maybe your next garage, I highly recommend it.

I also ran a gas line into the garage when it was built with the idea that I could install a gas heater on the wall or ceiling, but because of the basement beneath, I haven't needed it.

Sorry, the above may not be much help... so now for something that may help you: I saw some drywall contractors nearby doing the spackling inside a new garage today, they used a kerosene "jet" heater. I'm not sure what it is called exactly, but it looks like a jet engine and it was really balmy in there, in spite of the fact that it was 20 outside and they only have paper over the door openings because the doors aren't installed yet.
 
I've got a vent-free propane wall mounted heater. It does have a blue flame, but needs no chimney- and it's thermostat controlled. I'm spoiled- I keep the garage a balmy 68*. I was skeptical of not needing a chimney at first, but it really works.
 
jscherb said:
Sorry, the above may not be much help... so now for something that may help you: I saw some drywall contractors nearby doing the spackling inside a new garage today, they used a kerosene "jet" heater. I'm not sure what it is called exactly, but it looks like a jet engine and it was really balmy in there, in spite of the fact that it was 20 outside and they only have paper over the door openings because the doors aren't installed yet.

Be careful of these as they can spit fireballs on occasion. I know somebody here in VA that it happened to and it burnt down his whole garage and car in it. Only reason he didn't lose the house was it was a detached garage.

Truck
 
I heat mine 30x60 with a wood stove and the same type of heater Randyzzz uses. Ventless propane they work great, the only drawback is they put alot of moisture in the air and are sensetive to dust. Why don't you want a wood stove in a shop that does wood work? I have had one for years and really like it. Its a great way to get rid of the scraps. I do have good dust collection though.
 
Since it is a woodworking shop, you will want to keep the temp pretty steady anyhow so no need for something that will heat it up quick. Also, the ventless propane heaters are out as you will not want to introduce the moisture. Plus, with the shop at a reasonable temp (say 65) it will be more convenient to go out and do a little something. Sometimes with wood working, all you may be able to do is glue a couple of boards together.

Would recommend either a small package unit heat pump or a window unit heat pump. While the package unit will have a better SEER rating, the window units that run on 240 volts isn't extremely bad. You can also buy a window heat pump that runs on 120 volts. Also, by going with either of these, you will also have the benefits of A/C in the same unit.

In regards to the insulation, would recommend R15 for the walls. Not readily available but can easily be ordered. A little bit more $, but worth it in the long run. For the ceiling, would recommend at least R30 or it will be hard to hold any heat in the building.

As far as leaving the rafters open, would reconsider that as well. The rafters will just hold the fine saw dust until you go to do a varnish job and then the dust will fall. While sheetrock is best, you can also just cover the rafters with 1/4 luan and then strip the seams with 1" strips. Easy quick job that doen't look too bad.

Don't have time to do much woodworking, but it can be very relaxing. Good luck with the shop.
 
I really don't want gas because I'd either have to mess with the bottles or I'd have to get another tank from the gas company. The tank for my house is too far away to run a line to the barn. I've used those kerosine jet heaters and I know I don't want that - too many fumes and I'd have to mess with keeping kerosine around, frequent trips to town to buy more, same with bottled propane. Wood just takes too long to get going and heat up a room. I've heated with wood in the past. I could be through with what I have to do sometimes by the time wood warms up the shop. A wood heater will take up too much space in my small shop anyway. I won't have that much scrap wood around. Most of my wood projects are carving bowls, spoons, and small projects. The shop will also give me a place to work on mowers, tiller, chainsaws etc. Radient floor heat would have been nice, but my concrete slab has been in place about 2 years so I can't retro fit it.

I guess it's a matter of figuring out how many watts and BTU's I will need for the square footage. Northern Tool has a decent selection of fan forced electric heaters. I'm leaning toward one that has 5000 watts and about 17000 BTU's. It will have to be wired into the building. Just wondered if anyone has experieince with electric heaters like this.
 
Robert Slone said:
The shop will also give me a place to work on mowers, tiller, chainsaws, engines, axles, trannies, brakes, light machining, welding, fabrication, bumpers, roll cages, trail armor, etc.

There, fixed it for you Robert ;)
 
bigwalton said:
There, fixed it for you Robert ;)


New shopping list: welder, hydrolic press, pipe bender,angle grinder, metal lathe.... (already have a sawsall :D ).
 
I have seen someplace an article on hydronic baseboard heaters powered by just a domestic water heater instead of a boiler. You can get an electric water heater.

I use a kerosene torpedo heater. My shop is pretty well insulated. You get used to the fumes but I usually shut it off at 55. I rarely use the wood working shop in the winter. Yesterday, it was below 20 in the shop.

At one time I had an electric downflow furnace mounted on the second floor. It was designed for a mobile home; bought it as damaged freight from a shipping company. Cost a bunch to use and I abanded it.
 
Last edited:
Robert, I'm using a 240v 4000w 13,000BTU elec. heat in my 23x23 x9'h attatched garage. Ceiling is sheet rocked. Our outside temp here will often be in the teens. Garage door is uninsulated. Its has a hard time getting it warm and the fan is always on high and to noisy. Electric is a good way to go for what your doing and my suggestion would be go with a bigger unit so you have the option the run the fan on a lower purrr speed. Makes for a more relaxing work space.
 
Back
Top