AWESOME WORK!!! (as usual)
just a thought... would the fender be able to support the weight of someone? you never know, someone might sit on it or step on it from the bed or something... wouldnt it be better to use wood to strengthen the fenders rather than gift wrapping tubes? gift wrapping tubes should only be used to beat up your friends ninja sword style..
Thanks!
If my plan was to build fenders that could be stepped on (either steel or fiberglass), first I'd put a diamond plate step on the top so the paint wouldn't get scratched

. But I'd also build an entirely different framework inside the fender to support weight, probably with some triangular steel brackets supporting the upper flat part of the fender against flexing down from weight.
My goal in adding the ribs built on the cardboard tubes wasn't actually strength, the goal was rigidity. The goal was to increase the rigidity of the fender so it didn't flex over bumps or at high speed. Fiberglass is far less rigid than steel, but in terms of flex, this fiberglass fender is much better than the heavy steel fender - the steel fender has so much mass it's hard to keep it from flexing a bit over bumps - the mass of the steel trumps the rigidity inherent in the steel.
At much less than half the weight of the steel fender, in this case the rigidity of the fiberglass fender trumps mass and there will be far less flex over bumps than the steel fenders, so that design goal was met.
But back to your question - what if someone stepped on the fender? First of all, if they did that and scratched my fenders they wouldn't live long enough to see if the fender supported their weight or not

. Seriously, though, I wouldn't want to step on either one - the steel might bend; the fiberglass might crack. Without an internal framework to support that kind of weight, I wouldn't want to step on either fender. Putting wood inside the fiberglass ribs instead of cardboard wouldn't actually improve the strength of the fender in the case where someone stepped on it, without some triangular bracing, the wood wouldn't do any more than the cardboard to prevent the fender from flexing at the ends of the ribs where they join the sides of the fender. The steel fender might take a permanent bend, and the fiberglass fender might crack, but the wood used as I used the cardboard wouldn't change that - some triangulation would be required.
Please don't step on my fenders, or my hood, or my hardtop... none of them are designed to be steps.
